Harry vs Edward


Harry Potter vs Edward Elric

For Both we'll be using Canon Material so for Edward we'll be using Brotherhood and 2003 adaptation and the Manga for Harry I'll be mostly using the Novels, Movies and anything which is considered canon.

Background

Harry Potter



Born July 31st 1980 Harry James Potter was the only child of James and Lily Potter. Harry was a special child a Prophecy once told that two children have the power to defeat the evil wizard Voldemort and Harry was one of them so the other being Neville Longbottom. After finding out about the prophecy Voldemort would attempt to kill Harry but Voldemort would be unsuccessful at killing Harry but his Parents would be killed during the attack. To keep him safe from Voldemort he would be brought to his aunt and uncle by Dumbledore who also place a charm on him which protected him from Voldemort. Due to his aunt resentment of Magic Harry was neglected and abused.

On his 11th Birthday Harry would receive letters from Hogwarts school of witchcraft but his aunt and uncle would change address to stop receive letters and not let Harry join Hogwarts. However after moving to somewhere else Dumbledore would come to pick up Harry himself and reveal he is a Wizard. After taking Harry from his aunt and uncle he would join Hogwarts and would be assigned into Gryffindor House where he would meet Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger and would become great friends with them. Harry would would make a name for himself. During The Triwizard Tournament the Tournament would end with the return of Voldemort. The next year Harry, Ron and Hermione would form a group called Dumbledore's Army which teaches Hogwarts students proper defense against against dark arts. Harry would fight in the Battle of department of mystery during the battle he would lose his godfather Sirius Black which also broke the prophecy.

Harry would also fight in the second Wizarding War where he alongside Ron and Hermione would hunt down and destroy Voldemort's Horcruxes. During the Battle of Hogwarts after seeing many allies perish he would confront Voldemort and nearly sacrificed himself knowing by doing so he would destroy the fragment of Voldemort's soul inside of him. After sacrificing himself he was brought into the Limbo where he would be given the choice to either live or move on he would chose to live and wake up and defeat Voldemort for once and for all.

After the war Harry would marry and have 3 children he would become an auror and help reform the Ministry of Magic. He would become head of the British auror office at 26 years old and in 2020 he would be promoted to Head of the department of magical law enforcement. 

Edward Elric


Born 1899 to Trisha Elric and Van Hohenheim Edward was raised by his single mom after his father suddenly disappeared. Even at a young age Edward had talent for Alchemy. Trisha would contract a illness and end up passing away leaving Edward and his brother Alphonse orphans. Edward and Alphonse would be taken care of Winry Rockbell a close friend of them and her grandmother. 

One day the boys had the idea to resurrect her mother with alchemy so they drew a Transmutation Circle and used everything they needed to resurrect their mother unfortunately the boys would be met by the Gate of Truth and by a being called the truth who takes Edward left leg and Alphonse's entire body. To not lose his brother Edward would sacrifice his right arm to imbue Alphonse's soul into a suit of Armor.

Years later the boys would become members of State Alchemist helping people around towns with the usage of alchemy and look for The Legendary Philosophers Stone. They would go through many adventures and discover many dark secrets such as that the Philosopher Stone is made up of imprisoned human souls. So Edward and Alphonse vowed to never use the Philosophers Stone.

In the end Edward would sacrifice his alchemy to give Alphonse his body back and would settle down with his childhood friend Winry Rockbell.


Abilities

Harry Potter

Spells


Harry has learn a lot of spells from a simple Avada Kedavra to scooping out a chunk of your enemy.
  • Avada Kedavra: can kill the enemy instantly however Harry has never used it and will mostly not use it as he restricts himself from using it.
  • Apparition: The user has to focus on the desired location and will be brought their immediately. (Instant Transmission)
  • Accio: allows the caster bring object close to them as long its in their sight.
  • Aguamenti (Water-Making Spell): creates a fountain of Water.
  • Ascendio: lifts the caster in the air.
  • Confringo: cause anything the spell touches to explode. (Killer Queen Daisan No Bakudan Bites Za Dusto)
  • Crucio: can cause the enemy to feel immense pain but it can not be used in anger it can only be used if the caster wants the person to feel pain.
  • Defodio: the caster can gouge a chunk off of their enemy.
  • Depulso: this spell pushes the enemy away from the caster.
  • Diffindo: this spell cuts anything it touches precisely and accurately.
  • Episkey: with this spell Harry can heal minor injuries, broken bones and cartilages.
  • Erecto: can be used to build a tent or other objects.
  • Expectro Patronum: a spirit like creature will be created by the casters positive emotions to defend from Evil creatures it can also be used to send messages to other Witches and Wizards.
  • Expelliarmus: disarms the opponent.
  • Feather-Light charm: makes something light.
  • Furnunculus: covers the enemy in boils or in pipmples.
  • Imperio: the enemy will be put in an Dream like state in which they will be subjected to the casters will they may resist it if they are also strong willed.
  • Inflatos: Inflates objects both living and dead.
  • Langlock: glues the enemies tongue to the roof of their mouth.
  • Levicorpus: dangles the enemy by their ankles upside down.
  • Liberacorpus: a counter to Levicorpus.
  • Locomotiv Mortis: Locks the legs together making the enemy unable to move in any way.
  • Lumos: creates a bright light at the tip of the wand which can be used like a torch.
  • Lumos Maximus: shoots a ball of light to where ever the wand is pointing.
  • Muffliato: creates a buzzing that makes them unable to hear.
  • Nox: turns off the light from Lumos.
  • Periculum: creates a red spark/flares that shoots out of the wand.
  • Point Me: the wand acts like a compass and points north.
  • Protego: creates a shield which reflects other spells towards the spell caster.
  • Protego Totalum: creates a shield which covers a small area that doesn't let anything through except Avada Kedevra, Imperio and Crucio.
  • Reducio: shrinks objects.
  • Reducto: disintegrates objects.
  • Refiling Charm: refills any container if the caster points at it.
  • Relashio: makes the enemy drop anything that they are gripping onto.
  • Rennervate: revives a stunned person.
  • Reparo: repairs objects.
  • Repello Muggletum: keeps any non-magical person away from wizarding places when they get close to it they will remember something important and do that instead.
  • Rictumsempra: tickles the enemy.
  • Riddikulus: used when fighting against Bogard it makes the Bogard appear as something funny to the caster making Bogard lose ability to scare the caster.
  • Sectrumsempra: creates gashes on the enemy like they were cut by a sword.
  • Shooting Spell: shoots object.
  • Stinging Hex: causes stinging on the enemy which leaves inflammations on the enemy. 
  • Stupefy: stuns enemies if used to forcefully it knocks them unconscious.
  • Switching Spell: switches two objects.
  • Wingardium Leviosa: levitates and moves whatever the caster points at.

Edward

Alchemy


Edward is a prodigy when it comes to using alchemy. Alchemy is basically manipulating matter using transmutation.
There are 3 steps to Alchemy

  • Analysis: The Alchemist must have full understanding of what there trying to transmutate including its composition.
  • Deconstruction: The Alchemist proceeds to break down matter on the atomic level. with this they can destroy whatever they wish to.
  • Reconstruction: The Alchemist can reconstruct the matter into whatever they want.

Transmutation

Edward can use this ability in many ways use it to for example use to turn any Elemental into a weapon when he used blood to make weapons due to its Iron composition. Another thing he can do is transform himself into a Philosopher Stone. 


Deconstruction

Deconstruction allows the Alchemist to destroy the enemies Body entirely.

Healing

By turning himself into a Philosophers Stone can heal fatal wounds. This Technique is dangerous however as it takes away a bit of the Alchemist's Lifespan.

Weapons and Equipment

Harry Potter

Wand


The wand is Harry's essential to cast spells whilst he can cast some spells without using the wand but its more versatile.

Invisibility Cloak


A magical Cloak which could render who over is covered Invisible. This was used by Harry's father during his time in Hogwarts but then was given to Harry by Dumbledore.

Firebolt


a Magical Broom that Harry uses throughout his Time. The Broom can fly at 150 miles per hour.


Marauder's Map


A map that can show every single room corner and secret passage.


Edward

Automail Arm


Edward uses an Automail Arm he has worn around 3 Automail Arms one built by Winry Rockbell which was mostly Steel. 

His second Automail Arm was given to him after his fight with Scar which was made with Chrome to make it more rust-resistant. 

His 3rd and last arm was given to him whilst traveling the colder regions which was composed of flexible cold resistant aluminium-carbon nanotube fiber which was more compatible with his Alchemy and it was lighter.

Blade


Ed can transmutate his automail arm into a Blade.

Spear


A Spear that Ed can throw or use for close-quarters combat.

Cannons


Ed can also create Cannons.

Hands


by touching the ground Edward can create hands that can grab his opponents.

Staff

Spikes

by touching the ground Edward can create Spikes from the ground that can pierce his enemies.

Hax

Harry

  • Supernatural Willpower: resisted Imperius Curse.
  • Magic
  • Flight: with Firebolt
  • Paralysis Inducement: via Stupefy
  • Healing/Regeneration: via Episkey
  • Invisibility: via Invisibility Cloak
  • Forcefield Creation: via Protego
  • Teleportation: via Apparition
  • Explosion Manipulation: via Confrigo
  • Creation/Summoning: Expectro Patronum
  • Size Manipulation: via Reducio
  • Death Manipulation: via Avada Kedavra
  • Light Manipualtion: via Lumos
  • Pain Manipualtion: via Crucio
  • Water Manipulation: via Aguamenti
  • Air Manipulation: via Wingardium Leviosa
  • Sound Manipulation: via Muffliato
  • Memory Manipulation: via Repello Muggletum
  • Deconstruction: via Reducto
Resistances

Mind Manipulation and Telepathy: via Occlumency trained by Snape to fend off Voldemort's influence
BFR: via Vanishing Spell
Curse Manipulation
Underwater Breathing: via Gillyweed

Edward

Feats

Harry Potter


  • Won the Triwizard Tournament at the age of 14
  • Defeated Voldemort
  • Fought in the second Wizarding War
  • Fought in the Battle of Hogwarts
  • Became the head of the department of magical law enforcement

Strength

Speed


Durability




Edward

Feats

  • Defeated Pride
  • Managed to restore his brothers original body
  • Defeated Greed
  • Trained under Izumi Curtis
  • Fought Scar numerous times

Strength



Speed



Durability

Harry

Other Wizard


Miscellaneous Characters


Weaknesses

Harry Potter


Harry needs his Wand to perform most of his spells whilst he can use some without it its more versatile. He also has horrible eyesight so if he's glasses are gone he can't see at all. His Scar on his Forehead causes him great pain whenever he was near Voldemort.


Edward is a prodigy Alchemist but he also has weaknesses without his Automail Arm he can't perform any Alchemy rendering him useless he's also a bit hothead and his Temper rises easily especially when his height is mentioned.


Verdict

Strength: Strength wise Edward is Small Town to Town Level at a lowball via creating walls around a Mountain scaling to Von Hohenheim and making giants which get to 1.79, 4.12 and 9.17 but this is Nothing compered to Harry who scales to Dumbledore covering London in fog coming out to 29.21 Kilotons. However if we take in the Philosopher Stone for Edward it changes as the Stone can wipe town which comes out to around 190.6-672.6 Kilotons which is nothing compared to Von Hohenheim using his Soul to power up a Transmutation circle which comes out to around 5.03 Petatons if we compare this to Harry's best which is 798.10 Gigatons this makes Edward 6000 times stronger of course if he uses the Philosophers Stone which he vowed to never use. 

Speed: Harry is faster as he scales to characters such as Hermione who can dodge spells and he defeated Voldemort who can block spells coming out to 2.14 times lightspeed. Even at a Lowball Edwards best is Mach 20.05 but Harry can dodge Voldemort's Lightning which comes out to Mach 70.92. So Harry gets this point

Hax: Edward does have a lot of Hax but they are nearly all close range as Edward needs to touch Harry to use them. If he plans to trap him in some sort of object he also needs to sacrifice something like when he put Alphonse Soul into the suit of armor he lost his arm afterwards whilst Harry has spells that are busted such paralysis Edward making him unable to move, sneaking up on him with his cloak and lets not talk about Avada Kedavra which is a one-shot move only Harry hasn't use this in the Movie's nor Novels and he will never use it due to his moral code. But this still goes to Harry as he can do other stuff such as shrinking Edward. This Point also goes to Harry.

Equipment: like mentioned in the Hax section most of Edwards Weapons are mostly close range which means he has to get up close and personal but thats gonna be hard for some who can simply fly away, teleport or be Invisible. The only weapons that he could use are spears, cannons and those hands which come out the ground but they have to catch Harry first and with a speed difference that massive I highly doubt that Edward can catch Harry with any of of his long range weapons. Harry's Equipment is just way better a flying broom and a Invisible Cloak is way better. This point goes to Harry.



Summary

Harry Potter


Advantages

  • Is Stronger if Edward doesn't use Philosophers Stone
  • Is faster
  • Way better Hax's
  • Avada Kedavra could kill Edward instantly
  • better equipment
  • Better Healing option
  • Can shrink Edward

Disadvantages

  • Is weaker if Edward uses the Philosophers Stone
  • won't use Avada Kedavra due to Moral Code
  • has no resistance against Deconstruction as it targets someone at the Molecular level
  • if he losses his glasses he's wide open
  • Isn't as experienced
  • Worse training


Edward Elric



Advantages

  • Is Stronger with Philosopher Stone
  • Harry has no answer to Deconstruction
  • Smarter
  • more Experience
  • better training
  • Hotter and Cuter Wife

Disadvantage
  • Is slower
  • worse hax's
  • Is weaker without Philosopher Stone
  • no answer to Avada Kedavra
  • Worse Healing option

Conclusion

In conclusion Harry has way more Hax better Equipment and due to the Speed difference is taking this Win


The Winner is Harry Potter


Happy New Years I'll mostly likely won't another post until January

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Knuckles vs Piccolo

Image
  Knuckles vs Piccolo For this well be Canon Material so no Archie or no Xeno only Manga, Anime and Games. Both of them are getting their usual equipment so no Dragon Balls or No Item boxes as Knuckles doesn't have them on him. Background Piccolo After Demon King Piccolo was defeated by the hands of Son Goku with the last of his power to spit out an egg to create his son Piccolo Jr who would avenge him . After hatching Piccolo trains for 3 years until the 23rd World Martial Arts Tournament where he would face off against Goku after a long battle Piccolo would lose but Goku would let him live to have him as a rival to fight against Piccolo would continue training during that time until one day he would encountered by a Saiyan Warrior named Raditz who found him whilst looking for Goku after Piccolo used his most powerful attack against Raditz which didn't faze him at all Raditz would pick up another high Power Level and Ignore Piccolo and fly to his new target. Piccolo would foll...
Read more

Kazuma Kiryu vs Jotaro Kujo

Image
 Kazuma Kiryu vs Jotaro Kujo Before we Begin We'll be using all the Canon Mainline games for Kiryu so Yakuza 0 to Infinite Wealth as for Jotaro we'll be using Jojo Manga and Anime and other statements. Kazuma Kiryu Born on 17th of June 1968 Kiryu's parents were killed by Shintaro Kazama when he was young feeling guilty Kazama adopted Kiryu and raised him in his Orphanage. Kiryu grew up alongside Akira Nishikiyama and Yumi Sawamura they grew so close they ended up becoming a Family. Both Kiryu and Nishiki grew up looking up to Kazama wanting to become a Yakuza like him. After confronting and begging Kazama to become Yakuza the next night they would become members of the Yakuza. Its 1995 Kiryu was told to meet Kazama in the Family Headquarters to discuss his own clan but its gets interrupted by Nishiki calling Kiryu and telling him that Yumi was kidnapped by Dojima's men Kiryu would end up pursuing them despite Kazama telling him not too. Kiryu would find Dojima shot dead...
Read more